Table of Contents
For most traditional Edinburgh sandstone buildings, a correctly specified lime mortar is more suitable than hard modern cement pointing. Lime is generally softer and more permeable, allowing moisture to leave through the joints. Dense cement-rich pointing can redirect moisture and stress into softer sandstone, increasing the risk of edge erosion, spalling and decay.
City of Edinburgh Council’s 2025 heritage guidance states that repointing should use traditional materials compatible with the existing wall, such as lime. It specifically says cement should not be used for repointing sandstone or brick buildings. Edinburgh also has 50 conservation areas, making compatible traditional repair particularly relevant across the city.
At Edinburgh Borders Roofing, our stonemasonry service includes lime pointing, stone restoration and stone conservation for traditional properties across Edinburgh, the Lothians and the Scottish Borders. Our website states more than 30 years of experience working with stone buildings.
In this guide, we explain how lime and cement mortar behave differently, why hard pointing can damage sandstone, how existing mortar should be assessed, and what to check before repointing begins.
Lime vs Cement Pointing
Lime mortar is generally softer, more vapour-permeable and better able to accommodate small movements than modern Portland-cement-rich mortar. Cement is usually harder and denser. On traditional porous sandstone, that difference affects where moisture leaves the wall and which material carries the stress.
| Feature | Lime mortar | Hard cement-rich mortar |
| Relative hardness | Usually softer | Usually harder |
| Moisture movement | More permeable | Generally denser |
| Small masonry movement | More accommodating | Less forgiving |
| Traditional sandstone compatibility | Usually appropriate | Often unsuitable |
| Weathering | Mortar can act sacrificially | Stone may weather first |
| Appearance | Can match historic texture | Often visually harder/greyer |
| Repair approach | Renewable | Can be difficult to remove safely |
Historic Environment Scotland explains that lime has been widely used in traditional Scottish buildings for pointing, bedding, render and other masonry work. Modern cement mortars became widespread much later.
The correct decision still depends on the building, existing mortar and exposure.
Why Edinburgh Sandstone Needs Lime
Traditional sandstone walls need mortar that works with the stone rather than overpowering it. Suitable lime mortar lets moisture move through the joints and provides a relatively sacrificial material that can weather before valuable masonry does.
Many of Edinburgh’s tenements, villas and historic buildings use solid sandstone construction.
Unlike many modern cavity walls, these buildings were designed to handle moisture through permeable materials. The goal is not to create an impermeable outer shell.
Historic Environment Scotland describes traditional lime mortars as materials that help weatherproof buildings while still allowing moisture movement.
This balance is particularly important during Edinburgh’s repeated wetting, drying and winter weather.
How Cement Can Damage Stone
Hard cement pointing can damage softer sandstone when it becomes stronger and less permeable than the surrounding masonry. Water then struggles to evaporate through the joint and may move through the stone instead, increasing deterioration around the stone edges and face.
City of Edinburgh Council warns that mortar should never be stronger or denser than adjacent stone. Its guidance explains that overly dense pointing can prevent drying through the joints and accelerate stone decay.
Common warning signs include:
- sandstone breaking beside hard joints
- flaking stone faces
- eroded stone edges
- very hard grey pointing
- cracks forming beside mortar
- persistent damp
- patchy previous repairs
- salt deposits or surface deterioration
The mortar can remain apparently intact while the sandstone around it becomes weaker.
That is the opposite of how a traditional sacrificial mortar joint should perform.
What Does Breathable Mean?
A breathable mortar allows water vapour to move through the wall and evaporate. It does not mean rain simply passes through the joint. Correctly specified lime mortar helps manage moisture while still providing a weather-resistant joint between masonry units.
Traditional walls inevitably become damp at times.
Rain, indoor moisture and seasonal conditions introduce water into building fabric. The important issue is whether that moisture can leave again.
Historic Environment Scotland explains that free movement of water vapour is essential within traditional construction.
This is why permeability matters alongside strength.
A mortar selected only because it seems “stronger” can perform worse when that strength makes it incompatible with the masonry.
The EBR Five-Point Check
Before repointing, assess five connected factors.
| Check | What matters |
| Condition | Which joints have actually failed? |
| Construction | What stone and wall type are present? |
| Compatibility | Is the mortar softer and suitably permeable? |
| Character | What colour, aggregate and joint profile match? |
| Curing | Can fresh lime be protected from poor weather? |
This avoids treating every building with the same standard mortar mix.
Historic Environment Scotland advises considering the existing mortar’s function, masonry condition, climate, exposure and desired appearance before selecting replacement mortar.
Should Cement Be Removed?
Cement pointing should not automatically be hacked out simply because it contains cement. Removal can damage sandstone edges. Where cement is cracked, separating from the stone or clearly contributing to deterioration, careful selective removal may be appropriate.
This is an important area where simplistic advice can cause more damage.
Historic Environment Scotland’s conservation standards say strongly adhered cementitious pointing can sometimes be safer to leave temporarily than remove aggressively. Where it is open, cracked or causing evident stone erosion, removal should be carried out carefully.
City of Edinburgh Council also advises that joints should not be widened during repointing. Its guidance says careful hand-tool removal is appropriate and warns against indiscriminate power-tool use.
Protecting the stone arrises is critical.
How Is Lime Mortar Chosen?
There is no single lime mortar specification for every Edinburgh building. The correct mix depends on the existing masonry, original mortar, location, exposure, joint dimensions and required finish. Mortar analysis may be useful where the original specification is unclear.
Lime mortar contains a binder, aggregate and water. The choice of aggregate affects texture, colour and performance. Different lime binders also behave differently.
Historic Environment Scotland notes that air limes, natural hydraulic limes and other lime products have different characteristics. Modern formulated products can also vary significantly.
That means “use NHL” is not a complete specification.
The mortar should be chosen for the wall.
Colour and texture also matter on traditional Edinburgh façades. A technically compatible mortar can still look wrong if the aggregate or joint finish does not respect the existing masonry.
How Is Repointing Done?
Good repointing involves removing defective material carefully, cleaning the joint, selecting compatible mortar, filling the joint thoroughly and finishing it to suit the original masonry. Fresh lime then needs suitable protection while it cures.
A typical process is:
- Survey the masonry and existing mortar.
- Identify only defective or inappropriate joints.
- Remove failed mortar without widening joints.
- Clean loose debris from the joint.
- Prepare the masonry appropriately.
- Pack compatible lime mortar into the joint.
- Finish the joint to match the building.
- Protect fresh work during curing.
Historic Environment Scotland’s Technical Advice Note on lime mortars covers preparation, specification and site practice for repointing traditional buildings.
Rapid drying, heavy rain and frost can affect fresh lime work, so weather protection forms part of the repair rather than an optional extra.
Does Every Joint Need Repointing?
No. Sound traditional mortar should normally be retained where it continues to perform correctly. Wholesale removal can unnecessarily destroy original building fabric and can damage stone edges during cutting out.
A condition-led survey should separate:
- sound original mortar
- soft but functional mortar
- open joints
- washed-out joints
- damaging cement repairs
- active masonry cracks
- areas where stone itself has failed
Historic Environment Scotland’s broader conservation approach favours retaining viable traditional fabric rather than replacing it simply because it looks old.
Repointing is maintenance, not façade resurfacing.
Listed Buildings and Pointing
Listed buildings and conservation-area properties need particular care because mortar colour, texture, joint profile and material compatibility contribute to architectural character. Like-for-like repair is different from changing the appearance or construction of the façade.
Edinburgh currently has 50 conservation areas.
The Council’s 2025 guidance says repairs matching original materials and methods and not affecting character do not usually require listed building consent or planning permission. It also warns that inappropriate repair materials can accelerate decay.
For sandstone repointing, the same guidance explicitly supports compatible traditional materials such as lime and rejects cement mortar for repointing sandstone or brick buildings.
If work involves broader alteration rather than straightforward repair, check consent requirements before starting.
What If the Stone Is Already Spalling?
Repointing alone cannot restore sandstone that has already lost substantial surface material. The first step is to stop incompatible moisture conditions and then assess whether the damaged stone needs conservation, mortar repair or carefully matched stone replacement.
Cement pointing is only one possible contributor to stone decay. Gutters, downpipes, defective copes and persistent water exposure should also be checked.
Edinburgh Borders Roofing provides dedicated stonemasonry services for stone restoration, conservation and lime pointing.
Where high-level masonry or chimney pointing is involved, appropriate access may also be necessary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lime Better Than Cement for Sandstone?
For most traditional Edinburgh sandstone, suitable lime mortar is generally more compatible than hard modern cement mortar. It is usually softer and more permeable, allowing moisture to leave through joints instead of concentrating deterioration within the stone.
Why Is Cement Bad for Old Stone?
Dense cement can be stronger and less permeable than old sandstone. This can shift moisture and stress into the stone, contributing to edge decay, spalling and trapped damp instead of allowing the mortar joint to weather sacrificially.
Should All Cement Pointing Be Removed?
No. Aggressive removal can damage stone. Sound, strongly bonded cement may sometimes be safer to leave until intervention is justified. Cracked, detached or demonstrably damaging cement can be carefully removed by skilled operatives.
What Type of Lime Mortar Is Best?
There is no universal mix. The specification should reflect the masonry, existing mortar, exposure, joint form and building condition. Historic mortar analysis can help where the original material is unclear.
Can Lime Pointing Be Done in Winter?
Cold, wet and frosty conditions can interfere with lime curing. Work needs appropriate scheduling and protection, so weather conditions should form part of the pointing plan rather than being ignored.
Does Lime Pointing Stop Damp?
Lime pointing can help a traditional wall manage moisture correctly, but it is not a cure for every damp problem. Leaking gutters, downpipes, failed stone details or other water sources should be corrected as part of the investigation.
Does Listed-Building Pointing Need Consent?
Like-for-like repairs using compatible original materials and methods do not usually require consent when character is unchanged. Alterations are different, so check with the City of Edinburgh Council where the proposed work changes historic fabric or appearance.
Summary
For traditional Edinburgh sandstone, lime vs cement pointing is mainly a question of compatibility. Suitable lime mortar lets the wall manage moisture and movement while protecting the stone. Hard cement-rich pointing can become too dense or strong, causing the surrounding sandstone to deteriorate instead.
The best repair starts by checking the stone, original mortar, previous repairs, exposure and joint condition before specifying a new mix.
Explore Edinburgh Borders Roofing’s stonemasonry service for lime pointing, stone restoration and conservation, or arrange a free photographic survey where high-level masonry needs inspection.
You can also visit our Edinburgh roofing team at 2 Anderson Pl, Edinburgh EH6 5NP to view our local Google Business Profile and business details.
